Pros and Cons of Using ERP Systems for Accounting

Is your accounting team spending more time wrestling with spreadsheets than actually helping you understand if your business is making money? You're not alone. Many businesses find themselves stuck in a cycle of manual data entry, information scattered across different programs, and financial reports that arrive too late to be useful.
Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems offer a potential solution by connecting your accounting functions with other parts of your business. But are they worth the investment? Let's explore the advantages and realistic challenges of implementing an ERP system for your accounting needs.
What's Not Working with Traditional Accounting Methods

Before looking at ERP solutions, let's talk about the everyday headaches that come with traditional accounting approaches:
- Too much manual work: Typing the same numbers into different systems wastes hours and leads to mistakes
- Can't see the full picture: Getting a clear view of how much money you have and where it's going requires pulling data from multiple places
- Month-end closing drags on: Matching up numbers across different systems can stretch your closing process from days into weeks
- Growing pains: As your business expands, you keep needing more accounting staff just to keep up with paperwork
Many businesses reach a point where their accounting processes are actually holding them back instead of helping them move forward.
The real advantages of ERP systems for accounting
Let's look at how ERP systems can actually make your accounting processes easier and help your business run better. These benefits go beyond just saving time on bookkeeping tasks.
Save time and money
ERP systems can dramatically cut the hours spent on routine accounting tasks. By automating repetitive work and eliminating duplicate data entry, your team can focus on more valuable activities:
- Process invoices in minutes instead of hours
- Close your books in days instead of weeks
- Reduce errors by catching them automatically
- Free up your accounting team to help you spot trends and opportunities instead of just entering data
These time savings translate directly to dollar savings. According to industry data, businesses can reduce accounting staffing costs by 64-75% compared to traditional approaches. For example, an Accounts Payable Specialist in major US cities (California, New York, Illinois, Texas and Florida) costs $5,000-$8,300 monthly compared to $1,700-$2,000 for the same role with ERP expertise working remotely.
See what's actually happening with your money
One of the most valuable benefits of ERP accounting is getting a clear, up-to-date picture of your financial situation:
- Check your cash position right now, not three weeks from now
- See easy-to-understand dashboards showing if you're making or losing money
- Get automatic alerts when bills are due or when expenses are higher than expected
- Keep better records for tax time and audits
With an ERP system, you don't have to wait until month-end to know if you can afford new equipment or need to cut back on expenses. Having accurate numbers at your fingertips means you can make better choices about where to spend or save.
Help your business grow smarter
Beyond just making accounting easier, ERP systems provide practical advantages that can help your whole business:
- Make decisions based on facts, not guesses: See which products, services, or customers are actually profitable
- Grow without drowning in paperwork: Add new product lines or locations without having to hire armies of accountants
- Get everyone on the same page: Sales, inventory, and finance teams all work from the same information
- Stay ahead of competitors: Respond quickly when market conditions change because you know exactly where you stand
Save money in the long run
While ERP systems require an upfront investment, they pay off over time:
- Financial Analyst positions show 74% cost savings compared to US hiring rates ($2,000-$2,700 vs. $8,400-$14,000 monthly)
- Finance Controllers with ERP expertise offer 75% savings ($3,000-$5,000 vs. $13,200-$20,300 monthly)
- Reduce or eliminate costs for multiple different software subscriptions
- Spend less time and money fixing errors and tracking down problems
For businesses watching their bottom line, these cost advantages make a real difference in profitability.
Important Things to Consider Before Jumping In
While the benefits are clear, it's important to know what you're getting into:
Initial costs and when you'll see returns
- There are upfront costs for software, setup, and training
- Most businesses start seeing returns within 1-2 years
- Cloud-based options often cost less to get started and implement faster
Getting your team up to speed
- Plan for 3-6 months to implement the core accounting functions
- Your staff will need time to learn the new system
- Having a clear plan for transitioning from old to new systems is crucial
Finding the right fit
- Not all ERP systems are created equal - finding one that matches how your business works is essential
- Some customization is usually needed to match your specific processes
- Balance customizing too much with keeping the system updatable
How to Get the Most from Your ERP Accounting System

To make your ERP investment really pay off, consider these practical approaches:
Smart implementation steps:
- Start with the basics like general ledger and accounts payable before adding more complex features
- Roll it out in stages to avoid disrupting your daily operations
- Set clear goals to measure if the system is actually helping
- Get expert help from people who've done this before
Consider mixing and matching your team for the best results:
- Train your current staff on the new ERP processes
- Bring in specialists to help with setup and optimization
- Look into remote team members with ERP experience for ongoing work
Our data shows that a Staff Accountant with ERP experience costs $5,700-$9,300 monthly in major US business centers compared to $1,800-$2,200 for remote options - a 72% reduction in costs.
Is an ERP Accounting System Right for Your Business?
To figure out if your business would benefit from an ERP accounting system, ask yourself:
- Is your accounting team constantly working overtime just to keep up with the basics?
- Do you often make decisions without knowing your current financial situation?
- Is your business growing but your accounting processes are stuck in the past?
- Are you discovering financial problems only after it's too late to fix them?
If you answered yes to two or more of these questions, an ERP accounting system could make a real difference for your business.
Making a Smart Choice
When looking at ERP options for your accounting needs, consider:
- What specific problems you need to solve
- How much you can spend now and what savings you expect later
- How it will work with your other business software
- What kind of help you'll need during setup and afterward
Remember that the right system should adapt to how you do business, not force you to completely change your processes.
Take the Next Step Toward Better Accounting
Setting up an ERP accounting system is a big move that can transform how you track and manage your money. The time and cost savings, improved visibility, and practical business advantages make sense for most growing companies.
Ready to see how an ERP accounting system might help your specific business?
Schedule a free, no-pressure conversation to discuss your needs and potential savings. Our team can help you figure out the right approach without the typical sales pitch.
Contact Atticus today to start moving toward simpler, smarter accounting processes.
Frequently Asked Questions

Compare NetSuite ERP talent salaries
Attracting top NetSuite talent with clear job descriptions is the first step. Understanding salaries is your next key move! Download this free salary guide to view talent costs, offshore hiring tips, and more
Learn how to scale your business

What is Your Strategy for Finding Rare Skill Sets like NetSuite Accountants?
Join our talented team. We are a small, passionate team with a commitment to hiring the best.
